Published November 19, 2026
Waiting Until Spring to Sell Your Home Could Cost You $8,000
Every year about this time I hear the same question: should I take my home off the market for the holidays and wait until spring? If your home has not sold and you are thinking about pulling it until after the holidays, there are a few things you really need to factor in before you make that call.
1. What will change when you re-list?
Start with the feedback from the showings you have had, and study it carefully. What is the general feedback you are hearing? Are people saying it is overpriced and making no offers? Are they saying it smells funny, the decor does not align, it needs too much work, or it is dirty? In that feedback are the hints of what you need to do to get your home sold.
If you pull the home off the market and put it back on in the spring with the same approach, the same plan, the same property condition and the same price, you have to really think that through, because that is probably a plan that is not going to work.
And whatever the feedback keeps bringing up, address it. I use the example of the hot pink bathroom. I see that color in some of the older Ramblers, and if everybody who shows the property brings up the hot pink bathroom as a showstopper, well, you better paint that bathroom. Do not just assume it is going to go away. If you want to sell, you have to get serious about those things.
Same with price. If you are hearing price high, price high, price high and getting no offers, you have to take a look at your price. Just being honest, I do not think that is going to change in the spring. In most cases it is a big gamble to bet that if you cannot sell it in the fall at this price, you will be able to sell it in the spring at that price.
2. The cost of waiting
The second thing to consider is what waiting actually costs you. Let us say your monthly expense is $2,000, and I think that is probably low for a lot of homes. Factor in your utility costs, maybe your association fees, the maintenance of the property, snow removal, whatever it might be, plus your monthly mortgage payment. Say it is $2,000 a month.
Hold the home for four months before you go back on the market and that is an $8,000 expense. At what gain? Maybe prices go up and you can sell for $10,000 more in the spring. In that example it would be a $2,000 gain, a simple holding-cost illustration, not a complete profit calculation. But what happens if the market goes south while you wait? Holding just to hold has a serious cost to it. Waiting might still be the right call for you, but it is something you need to calculate and look at carefully.
3. If you stay on, study your competition
If you are going to stay on the market, look at your comparative market analysis. Your agent should be able to go over this with you. Look at the market as a whole: what are you actively competing against today?
Here is the cool thing about staying on during the holiday months: a lot of people do decide to pull their home off the market, and that reduces your competition. Put yourself in a buyer's shoes. If you were looking for a home that hit the rough specs of your property, what other homes would you be looking at? Take a hard look at where you lie.
If there are ten other listings you are competing against that are all kind of similar, it might make sense to wait until spring. But if there are only two other properties that are somewhat relevant and you think you are number one or maybe number two, you might want to really consider staying on, because that is a great market for you to sell in.
4. Say yes to showings
If you decide to stay on during the holidays, you have to make your home accessible. If your home is on the market but you are challenging to the agents who want to show it, denying showings or suggesting other times, you do not know how big of an impact that has.
Whenever agents request showings, accommodate them at the time and date they request. When buyers tour, they are often looking at two or three homes in one outing, and your home is being fit into that schedule. If you are the one they cannot get into, you will probably get bumped, and if they fall in love with another one, they may write an offer without ever comparing it to yours.
5. Relisting does not reset your days on market
There is a common misunderstanding that if you cancel your listing, take it off for the holidays and go back on in the spring, it wipes out your days on market. In our market, it does not work that way. Buyers' agents look at how long a home has been on the market, and while relisting starts a fresh counter for that particular listing, right next to the days on market is the CDOM: the cumulative days on market. That is what the agent world sees here.
So agents will generally know the home was on the market before, and they can see the pricing history too. If a listing looks brand new but shows 160 cumulative days, we can quickly look at the history. Going back on at the same price 160 days later signals a seller who is not understanding the market or changing with it. You do get a slight benefit, because the home pops up as a new listing, but as soon as someone clicks, they can see it has been on the market for a minute, whether that is 100, 160 or 200 days.
The bottom line
Do not make this decision on autopilot. Compare the two plans: the cost of waiting and your possible upside if you hold for spring, against the reality of staying on the market now, with changes if you need them. We sell properties year round, every month, every week and every day. The holidays have an impact, but they also bring less competition, and that is worth a real look if you are a seller who wants to get your home sold. If you are thinking about selling in the Twin Cities, reach out and we can build a plan around your home and your timing. Outside the Twin Cities? I can help connect you with an agent in your area.
Free resource: Strategic Seller Blueprint
Want more tips to sell for the most money possible? Download our free Strategic Seller Blueprint.
Common questions
Should I take my home off the market during the holidays? It depends on three things: what your showing feedback says, what waiting actually costs you each month, and how much competition you face right now. The holiday months often mean less competition, because other sellers pull their homes off the market.
How much does it cost to wait until spring to sell? Use your real numbers: monthly mortgage payment, utilities, association fees, maintenance and snow removal, times the months you wait. At $2,000 a month, a four-month wait is an $8,000 expense, before you count any change in the spring market.
Can I relist in the spring at the same price? If buyers kept saying the price was high and made no offers, a new season alone usually does not fix that. In most cases, betting that a home that will not sell in the fall at one price will sell in the spring at the same price is a big gamble.
What should I change before relisting? Whatever your feedback keeps raising. If every showing mentions the same showstopper, like a hot pink bathroom, fix it before you come back. Relisting with the same approach, the same condition and the same price is probably a plan that will not work.
Does taking my home off the market reset my days on market? Not in our market. Relisting starts a fresh counter for that one listing, but agents still see the cumulative days on market and your pricing history, so the break does not make the home look brand new for long.
Thinking about selling in the Twin Cities?
Visit paulinghomes.com/selling to get started.
Billy Pauling | Pauling Homes Team | Keller Williams Premier Realty Lake Minnetonka
